top of page

College Essay Review: Personal Statements & Supplements

Expert written feedback from an experienced college essay coach, former English teacher, and working writer.

Most students approach the college essay as a story to tell.

Admissions readers are looking for something different: evidence of how a student thinks.

Recent Student Admits Include:

Harvard, Yale, Stanford, Princeton, MIT, Dartmouth,

UPenn, Cornell, Duke, Brown, Swarthmore, Tufts,

Georgetown, Emory, Tulane, Wake Forest, U Michigan.

NYU, Fordham, Hamilton, Carleton, Middlebury, Bowdoin, Smith, UCs, UCONN, URI, UMASS, Penn State, Washington U, William & Mary, University of FL, Notre Dame, Indiana U.

Testimonials

"Your patience and guidance made all the difference." — Sona, parent

"Kristie Schmidt had a well-known reputation in my school district for being the expert in college essay editing... I got accepted to every school on my list." — Melanie K., former student, now an LMSW clinical researcher

"Your help with my essay truly had a big impact on my acceptance." — Peter Pannullo, accepted Stony Brook University's Doctor of Physical Therapy program

"Since his preference is to have us be less involved, it's been invaluable to have someone like you help him along the way." — Katie, parent

"She tackles everything from a different perspective but always keeps your end goal and personal writing style in mind." — Jillian, student

"Next up is Henry... we'll be in touch next summer to do it all again!" — Josh, parent

Your student has written a college application essay. They've revised it, perhaps several times. The grammar is fine. The story makes sense. But something isn't quite working.

Maybe the essay describes an experience without revealing much about the person who had it. Maybe it sounds polished but generic. Or maybe your student has an interesting idea buried beneath three paragraphs of explanation.

The problem is often harder to diagnose than it is to fix.

I help students identify what's working in their college essays, what isn't, and where the writing needs to go next.

​

College Essay Feedback That Goes Beyond Editing

Strong college application essays reveal how students think. Their curiosity, judgment, humor, intellectual habits, and particular ways of seeing the world emerge through the choices they make on the page.

That doesn't happen automatically, even for accomplished students.

Some essays become inventories of achievements. Others linger over the circumstances of an experience without examining what the student made of it. Still others reach for a lesson the writer doesn't quite believe.

My job is to read beneath the surface of the draft and identify what the student is actually trying to say.

Sometimes that means finding the essay's real subject. Sometimes it means recognizing that the strongest material is already there, in a paragraph the student almost deleted.

The goal is a more compelling essay that remains recognizably the student's own work.

"I was so fortunate to have Kristie guide both of my daughters as they worked to create narratives that got noticed... It was such a proud moment when their essays received compliments during college interviews."

Verna, parent

How My College Essay Review Works

I offer a one-time, asynchronous written diagnostic for either a Common Application personal statement or a single college's supplemental essay set.

Student submits drafts of personal statement or supplemental set, activity list,

and resume, and a completed intake Google form.

 

I read for what's working, what's missing, and what the essay is actually about versus what the student thinks it's about.

They receive written margin comments and a synthesis letter identifying the most important revision moves.

 

Most students discover they've been writing about the wrong thing. The triage names that problem specifically and tells them exactly what to do about it.

One submission. One written response. No meetings, no follow-up obligation, no ongoing coaching relationship. Slots limited to four per month.

Essay Review: $325

Your student submits:

  • Their current essay draft or supplemental essay set
  • Their activities list and résumé
  • A completed student intake form

One submission. One written response. No meetings or ongoing commitment.

Review capacity is limited to four students per month.

I read the materials together to understand the student beyond the individual essay. Then I return detailed written feedback, including margin comments and a synthesis letter identifying the most important revision priorities.

The feedback addresses questions such as:

  • What does this essay reveal about the student's thinking and character?
  • Where does the writing become generic, repetitive, or overly explanatory?
  • What material deserves more attention?
  • Is the essay answering the actual prompt?
  • Which changes would make the greatest difference?

Your student receives a clear set of revision priorities rather than a collection of disconnected editing suggestions.

Why Work With Me?

I'm Kristie Schmidt, a college essay coach, former English teacher, and award-winning nonfiction writer.

I hold degrees from Smith College and Harvard University, trained under a former Cornell Director of Admissions, and have spent more than twenty years helping students develop writing for selective colleges and competitive programs.

My own writing has received the International Amy MacRae Award for Memoir. I know the difference between a piece that is technically competent and one that has found its subject, because I confront that distinction in my own work.

My experience as a teacher also matters. I know how to explain why a piece of writing isn't working and give a young writer a manageable way to approach revision.

Students I've coached have received offers of admission from institutions including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, MIT, Brown, Cornell, and many other colleges and universities.

Every student's admissions outcome depends on far more than an essay. My responsibility is to help them produce writing that represents them accurately and convincingly.

Who Benefits Most From a Written Essay Diagnostic?

This service is designed for students who already have a draft and are ready to revise it.

It's particularly useful for students who feel stuck, whose essays have become overworked, or who have received conflicting advice from parents, teachers, and friends.

It's also an option for families who prefer focused professional feedback without scheduling weekly coaching appointments or purchasing a comprehensive admissions package.

The student remains the writer. I provide the editorial judgment and a specific direction for revision.

Ready for an Expert Second Read?

I work remotely with students throughout the United States and internationally, including families in Connecticut and the surrounding region.

Whether your student is revising a Common App personal statement or preparing supplemental essays for a selective college, I can help them see what's already on the page and what still needs to emerge.

Availability is limited to four reviews per month.

bottom of page